NHS IT legal bill hits £2.6m in fight with Fujitsu

Contract dispute remains a difficult problem for Whitehall

The government has spent over £2.6m on legal costs to tackle an ongoing dispute with Fujitsu after the supplier left the NHS National Programme for IT 13 months ago.

The figure was revealed in a parliamentary answer, written by new health minister Mike O’ Brien.

Asked by the Conservatives how much how much had been spent on the “NHS IT dispute” with Fujitsu, he said: “As at 11 June 2009, payments for accountancy, and legal and associated professional services in connection with the dispute resolution process totalled some £2,613,000.”

NHS and Department of Health spokespeople could not be reached at the time of writing. Fujitsu declined to comment on the latest developments.

A source close to the programme told Computerworld UK that the parties were aiming to settle any fees for termination out of court, to avoid further protracting an already expensive process. But it not known how successful this process has been so far.

It is understood that Fujitsu may be looking for a "sizeable" termination fee, the source said, having spent large amounts of money rolling out the systems in the south of England. Fujitsu is thought to have received a small fraction of what it has spent, because the government pays on system delivery, and Fujitsu still had many NHS trusts to roll out systems to.

The contract was ended in May last year, after the NHS and Fujitsu had held protracted talks that failed to result in an agreement. They disputed the costs and work involved in delivering locally-tailored patient administration systems to hospital trusts.

Registration is free, and gives you full access to our extensive white paper library, case studies & analysis, downloads & speciality areas, and more.

At the time, the NHS said it chose to terminate the agreement. Fujitsu said trusts unfairly "withheld payment" until it delivered hundreds of changes beyond what it claimed was the agreed scope.

Work continues on the £12.7bn programme, with BT and CSC the only contractors. The latter has a £3bn contract.

The value of BT’s deal was dramatically increased earlier this month by half a billion pounds, to £1.57bn, after it took over some of Fujitsu's work. But analysts have speculated that its reported threats to quit the programme meant it had the NHS "over a barrel" in contract negotiations.



Email Updates

CIO Newsletters: Expert insight, advice and tools for technology, business, leadership and the CIO career.


Email this article to a friend or colleague:


PLEASE NOTE: Your name is used only to let the recipient know who sent the story, and in case of transmission error. Both your name and the recipient's name and address will not be used for any other purpose.


CIO White Papers

Creating an AUP: Common myths & mistakes

Avoid the common myths & mistakes when implementing your AUP

Unleashing the power of virtualisation 2010

Find out more about cloud computing in European enterprises.

Email archiving: Top 10 myths and challenges

This survey looks at a number of challenges and myths around email archiving that may also slow adoption of full archiving.

Modernising IT: Strategies for improving service quality and reducing IT costs

No matter how many people you allocate, sinking more labour into old IT practices cannot concurrently meet rising demands on IT and cut costs. Read about cost-effective, automated ways to meet this challenge head-on.


CIO UK - Business - Technology - Leadership

Differentiate your company with complete CRM

Focused on productivity and empowerment and leveraging the natural rhythms people work
What defines Complete CRM? How businesses can better engage customers and users, manage customer transactions, and analyse results to adapt and take advantage of changing business and economic circumstances.

DOWNLOAD

Oracle White Paper

IT Misuse Survey

Complete this survey and you could win a Nexus One.

CIO are running a short survey to discover how UK businesses are managing internet and email misuse in the Enterprise.

COMPLETE SURVEY

Virtualisation 2.0
Driving to higher ground beyond the basics

Virtualisation can deliver unparalleled efficiency and cost reductions to your business, allowing direct access to servers and guaranteeing a dependable, rapid response in times of crisis. Read this e-book to learn more about consolidation, discover the latest technologies and find out how to reduce the TCO of virtualisation.

DOWNLOAD

Trend Micro



* *