Knowledge Vault


Follow us





Information commissioner to take action on HMRC, MoD

Both depts breached Data Protection Act, says ICO

Information commissioner will take formal enforcement action against both HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC) and Ministry of Defence (MoD), following spate of high-profile data loss incidents.

Richard Thomas announced he would take action against HMRC for the loss of 25 million child benefit claims and MoD for the loss of a laptop containing unencrypted records on 600,000 recruits.

His announcement came after the publication of a series of reports that highlighted endemic failures around data security management within both departments. The Poynter report and a report from Independent Police Complaints Commission both lambasted HMRC for its "woefully inadequate" information security practices that led to a data breach incident that was "entirely avoidable".

Similarly, a report published by Sir Edmund Burton into the loss of data at the MoD, said the overall management of its recruitment project "lacked rigour".

The Burton report stated the MoD is "not treating information, knowledge and data as key operational and business assets".

It also said the department was in breach of several principles of the Data Protection Act when it implemented its recruitment database, called TAFMIS, on unencrypted laptops. However, the principles of the Act "are not precise: they require judgement. The department will therefore need to seek guidance on the exercise of that judgement from the Information Commissioner."

Thomas said all three reports revealed "deplorable failures at both HMRC and MOD" and it is "beyond doubt" that both departments have breached Data Protection requirements.

The Information Commissioner's Office (ICO) intends to serve formal enforcement notices on the agencies.

He also said that these breaches "are not isolated cases".

Registration is free, and gives you full access to our extensive white paper library, case studies & analysis, downloads & speciality areas, and more.

"It is deeply worrying that many other incidents have been reported, some involving even more sensitive data. It is of fundamental importance that lessons are learned from these breaches. Information security and other aspects of data protection must be taken a great deal more seriously by those in charge of organisations," he said. "No chief executive can now say that data protection doesn’t matter."

HMRC and the MoD will have to implement all the recommendations outlined in the reports to comply with the terms of the enforcement notices. The ICO said it will require progress reports to be published after 12, 24 and 36 months that documents how the recommendations have been implements to improve compliance.

Related stories:

MoD first to get cross-government travel booking service



Email Updates

CIO Newsletters: Expert insight, advice and tools for technology, business, leadership and the CIO career.


Send to a friend

Email this article to a friend or colleague:

PLEASE NOTE: Your name is used only to let the recipient know who sent the story, and in case of transmission error. Both your name and the recipient's name and address will not be used for any other purpose.


CIO White Papers

The financial economics of cloud email

This white paper evaluates cloud computing as a flexible alternative to your current IT capability that delivers tangible benefits including: projects delivered earlier, faster adoption to change, lower risk, reduced costs and easier to scale up or down services.

Beyond Dropbox: Requirements for Enterprise Secure File Sharing

This whitepaper explores the danger “Dropbox” type services pose for enterprises, and the security and compliance requirements for deploying enterprise-wide file sharing solutions.

Top 10 considerations for your IT operations management in the cloud

This paper explores ten questions every IT organization should answer to help determine their cloud based ITOM needs.

How to get your business ready for the 2012 Olympics

IT Manager: "I'm working on contingency plans to ensure that we can keep the business running whatever happens during the Olympics. Hopefully, it'll just be a case of letting people work from home but we need to be ready for anything".


CIO UK - Business - Technology - Leadership

Voice Applications in the Cloud

Watch this webcast to learn about new network and telecoms options.

Register now

Download the CIO BlackBerry App -
Access CIO's Content on the Move


The CIO UK BlackBerry App provides daily business and technology news, opinion and indepth features direct to your BlackBerry device.

Find out more

CIO Transformation Summit

CIO Roundtable:
The Private Cloud

Wed 29 Feb 2012
Tower 42, London, 7pm.

Join a select group of your fellow CIO's to discuss private cloud computing and how best to apply the private cloud to your organisation

Register here to book your place.



Knowledge Vault


* *