Supplier management by government is wasting £200bn

OGC needs to develop standard government approaches with suppliers, MPs say

Government projects worth a total of £200 billion are being put at risk by Whitehall's lack of commercial expertise, according to a damning report.

The value for money on 43 government projects, many of which are either IT focused or have a large technological component, is being put in a dangerous position because of “significant weaknesses” in the ability and background of government employees when it comes to dealing with suppliers.

This is the verdict of a new report by the National Audit Office, which blamed the government for failing to assess skills shortages systematically. The NAO said it was “critical” that government hired permanent staff who had the commercial skills and experience to interact with suppliers, rather than relying on contractors to assist with tackling the problem.

The biggest skills gaps were in contract management, commissioning and managing advisers, risk identification and management, and business acumen.

Fourteen out of 16 departmental commercial directors told the NAO that the Office of Government Commerce had done little to address skills gaps within their department. But the NAO said “ultimate responsibility” for commercial skills “remains with departments”.

While the OGC had introduced a number of initiatives aimed at improving commercial skills, it was not working closely enough with departments, the NAO said. It needed to work with departments to establish standard approaches for dealing with the commercial sector.

While the report did not single out individual projects, the 43 schemes referred to include the £12.7 billion NHS National Programme for IT, including summary care records, the data ‘spine’, and electronic prescriptions.

Registration is free, and gives you full access to our extensive white paper library, case studies & analysis, downloads & speciality areas, and more.

The ContactPoint database of children and the Building Schools for the Future scheme are also among the projects, alongside the Ministry of Defence’s £7 billion Defence Information Infrastructure programme and HM Revenue & Customs’ Pay As You Earn tax system.

On the list too are the Ministry of Justice’s C-Nomis National Offender Management System and its Libra court case management software, as well as the biometric passport and identity cards programmes, and the police Impact programme.



Email Updates

CIO Newsletters: Expert insight, advice and tools for technology, business, leadership and the CIO career.


Email this article to a friend or colleague:


PLEASE NOTE: Your name is used only to let the recipient know who sent the story, and in case of transmission error. Both your name and the recipient's name and address will not be used for any other purpose.


CIO White Papers

Enterprise mashup services

Mashups are part of the Web 2.0 evolution of IT that can empower a business to enhance productivity, innovate more readily and collaborate more effectively – both internally, and with suppliers, partners and customers

10 key actions to reduce IT infrastructure and operations cost structure

Infrastructure and operations leaders are under intensifying pressure to reduce costs. This research outlines the key actions they should take to change the I&O cost structure near term (through 2010) and longer term (during the next three years).

Unlocking the benefits of Google Apps

Download this whitepaper to learn more about how you can save time and money by migrating from Microsoft Exchange to Google Mail.

Achieving Control: The four critical success factors of change management

Improve IT business value with minimum impact on security compliance and IT infrastructure


CIO UK - Business - Technology - Leadership

Nimsoft  White Paper

Ensuring high service levels in cloud computing

Explore the most pressing challenges cloud computing presents in terms of service level management and how to overcome obstacles

A comprehensive overview of key issues organisations should be aware of before they make the plunge to cloud computing.

Read more


Advancing the security operations function

Traditional security operations programs, centered primarily on SIEM, have been long understood to be one of the most effective security investments an organisation can make. However, many organisations are finding that today’s high-risk environments are requiring more than just basic operations in order to effectively reduce risks. This white paper discusses a number of guidelines and considerations for implementing a more advanced approach to security operations.

Download the whitepaper

Enterprise communications and collaboration in a fast changing world

With capital expenditure budgets drastically reduced, the IT team is facing an unprecedented challenge: just how can it meet demands for more flexible working and improved productivity without embarking upon a sustained investment program.

Download the whitepaper




* *