CFO Expectations of IT


Follow us





Delayed IT upgrade causes armed forces pensioners to be underpaid

MoD waited more than a year for new IT system rather than install interim solution

Around 5,000 retired members of the armed forces have been underpaid their pensions due to a delay in upgrading an IT system managed by HP Enterprise Services.

The Ministry of Defence (MoD) said that the problem would not be solved until a new IT system was implemented in October.

“[The problems] would be solved by a change in the computer system. We are introducing a new IT system in October. It was more cost-effective to wait for the new system [rather than install a temporary fix in the meantime],” a spokesperson for the MoD said.

"The MoD and HP  are working together to resolve this issue as quickly as possible."

The pensioners affected are those who have retired since April 2010, and were members of the Armed Forces Pension Scheme 75 (AFPS 75) scheme. The scheme opened in April 1975 and closed to new joiners on 6 April 2005.

 It is estimated that each person has been underpaid by between £200 and £300 a year due to the error.

 “Those affected will be fully reimbursed and we apologise for any inconvenience caused,” the spokesperson added.

Under the AFPS 75 scheme, members can stop working after between 16 and 22 years depending on their position, and receive an early pension with a tax-free lump sum.

Members can choose to receive a larger lump sum payment immediately by temporarily giving up, or ‘commuting’ part of the early pension.

This means that they receive a lower annual pension until they are 55, which then goes back to the original level before the commutation.

The underpayments arose because the SPVA was supposed to change the way it calculated the commuted pension from April 2010, but it chose to wait for the introduction of a new computer system in October 2011 instead.

According to the BBC, Commander Michael Goldthorpe identified the problem when he retired from the Royal Navy in 2010 after 33 years of service.

Registration is free, and gives you full access to our extensive white paper library, case studies & analysis, downloads & speciality areas, and more.

When he started receiving his pension last September, he noticed it was about £311 a year lower than what his official pension had forecast.

Goldthorpe complained to the Service Personnel and Veterans Agency (SPVA), which runs the Armed Forces Pension Scheme (AFPS), and it admitted that there was a miscalculation due to “unforeseen delays in updating the compensation and pension system”.

He was also told that his pension forecast was inaccurate, which meant that he was underpaid by only £138 a year.

Meanwhile, the MoD has told him that employees who retired after November 2010 should have been alerted to discrepancies in their pensions by the department’s computerised pension forecasting system.



Email Updates

CIO Newsletters: Expert insight, advice and tools for technology, business, leadership and the CIO career.


Send to a friend

Email this article to a friend or colleague:

PLEASE NOTE: Your name is used only to let the recipient know who sent the story, and in case of transmission error. Both your name and the recipient's name and address will not be used for any other purpose.


CIO White Papers

The cloud 2015 vision

Cloud computing is an important transition and a paradigm shift in IT services delivery - one that promises large gains in efficiency and flexibility at a time when demands on data centers are growing exponentially. The tools, building blocks, solutions, and best practices for cloud computing are evolving and challenges to deploying cloud solutions need to be considered.

The consumerisation of technology

iPads are the must-have fad. Android is the rising mobile platform -- Everywhere you turn, the news is about personal, smart, mobile devices and their impact on business and on IT.

Big data analytics

Broadly, there are two ways to think of Big Data technologies. The first is as an extension of what many organisations are already doing with business analytics. Gaining insight from business information is something that has been happening for decades, but the challenges and opportunities are now greater than ever before.

Virtualisation: benefits, challenges and solutions

The majority of organisations have already implemented server virtualisation and most intend to implement additional server virtualisation during the next year. The primary factors driving the movement to deploy server virtualisation are cost savings and the ability to dynamically provision and move VMs among physical servers. There are however, a number of significant challenges associated with server virtualisation.


CIO UK - Business - Technology - Leadership

On Demand Webcast
Analyse Data In Real Time


Increasingly businesses require the ability to analyse information quickly. Find out how to handle growing data volumes more efficiently while reducing the cost of managing your organisation's IT landscape

Watch now

SAP Logo

What do CFOs expect from IT?


Watch our sister publication's latest webcast.
Hear a case study from the Guardian News and Media's Technology Director, Andy Beale, and join the discussion on the role of the CFO in technology innovation.

Watch Discussion

CFO World webcast in assocation with Google

On Demand Webcast:
Maximising business flexibility with virtualisation


Register for this on demand webcast and find out how technologies can enable cost effective and secure virtualisation from your server deployments.



Watch now

Dell VMware logo


CFO Expectations of IT


* *